(920) 499-2121 [email protected] 1052 Bel-Aire Ct Green Bay, WI 54304
Book Appointment

Tooth-Colored Fillings in Wisconsin

— restore your tooth without anyone knowing it was ever treated

Modern composite resin fillings are carefully matched to the natural shade of your teeth, creating a restoration that blends smoothly with your smile. At Bay Park Smiles, we use durable, tooth-colored materials to repair cavities while restoring the tooth’s natural appearance, strength, and function.

Biocompatible Matrix • No silver, no mercury, no compromise

Tooth-colored, mercury-free, and bonded directly to your tooth

Composite resin restorations represent a leap forward from historical metal filling frameworks. Unlike silver amalgam fillings, which are packed mechanically into a hollow space and require extensive tooth destruction, composite materials bond chemically directly to your natural enamel and dentin architecture.

This molecular adhesion reinforces and supports the remaining enamel structures from within, significantly decreasing the risk of future structural fractures.

Filling Parameters Baseline

Appointment Span: Single-visit delivery block

Anesthesia Protocol: Localized comfort tracking
Aesthetic Metric: Precisely shade-matched to natural tooth color
Structural Impact: Strengthens remaining tooth structure
Insurance Standard: Most plans cover • Same-day: yes
Amalgam Replacement Protocol

Is it time to upgrade your historical silver fillings?

Many patients with old silver amalgam fillings ask about having them replaced with tooth-colored composite. Here’s an honest answer about when it makes sense — and when it doesn’t.

Good reasons to replace amalgam

The filling is old, cracked, or failing

The tooth has developed secondary decay around the filling

You want a more natural appearance

The metal is visible when you smile or talk

You have mercury sensitivity concerns

When replacement may not be necessary

The filling is intact, well-sealed, and functioning well

Removing a sound amalgam involves additional drilling

No current clinical evidence requiring immediate amalgam removal in healthy patients

We'll assess each filling individually and give you an honest recommendation

Our approach to amalgam replacement

“We evaluate each amalgam filling on its own merits. If replacement is appropriate — due to age, failure, decay, or your preference — we remove it safely and replace it with a matched composite restoration. We never recommend replacement purely for commercial reasons.”

Material Bio-Metrics

The Key Performance Differences

Composite (tooth-colored)

Matches natural tooth color exactly

Bonds to tooth — strengthens structure

Requires less tooth removal

Mercury-free

Expands and contracts with temperature similarly to tooth

Amalgam (silver)

Silver/gray color — visible when speaking or smiling

Mechanically retained — doesn't bond to tooth

Requires more healthy structure to be removed

Contains mercury (stable when intact)

Can expand and crack tooth over time with temperature cycling

Clinical Workflow

The Filling Process — Done in One Visit

01

Anesthesia & prep

Local anesthesia applied. Decay or old filling material removed. Conservative — only what needs to come out comes out.


02

Shade matching

Composite resin shade selected to match natural tooth color precisely. The match is so accurate the filling is virtually invisible.


03

Placement & curing

Composite placed in layers and hardened with a curing light. Each layer shaped and polished to restore natural tooth contour and bite.


04

Done in one visit

Entire process completed in a single appointment. You leave with a finished, polished, fully functional restoration the same day.


Fillings that look natural and last

Mercury-free practice

We prioritize your long-term health values by relying exclusively on modern composite tooth restoration systems across all operations.

Precise shade matching

We take time to match composite shading to your natural tooth — including characterization, translucency, and surface texture. The result should be undetectable.

Conservative preparation

Composite bonding requires less healthy tooth structure removed than amalgam. We take the most conservative approach that serves you long-term.

Real Patient Feedback

Google reviews

Trusted by local families

4.9 ★★★★★ Google
mary paul
mary paul4 months ago
★★★★★

Everyone, from Dr. V., to hygienist Liz, to receptionists, were very friendly, welcoming, and professional….

Maurice Kane
Maurice Kane4 months ago
★★★★★

Very friendly and professional. There was no trying to find something wrong that "needs" fixing.

Mike Calawerts
Mike Calawerts6 months ago
★★★★★

Dr. Mark and his team are amazing! He is incredibly caring and good. Our whole…

SHARON PROCHASKA
SHARON PROCHASKA3 months ago
★★★★★

Pain free dentistry with Dr. Mark and great teeth cleaning with Lisa! They care about…

Larry Verheyden
Larry Verheyden2 months ago
★★★★★

I’ve been to three different dental places in the last year and a half trying…

Kay Woelfel
Kay Woelfel4 months ago
★★★★★

Dr mike as i call him is awesome and lisa my hygienist is also

Jodi Wittkopf
Jodi Wittkopf2 months ago
★★★★★

My first visit was a big win. Everyone there was very nice. I’ll definitely be…

T S
T S2 months ago
★★★★★

Going in with complications from a former dentist, and they had absolutely no problem taking…

Mary Bouche
Mary Bouche4 months ago
★★★★★

Had a cleaning and found the staff to be super friendly and efficient. Great experience!

John Jarvey
John Jarvey2 months ago
★★★★★

Employees very respectful and polite during complete procedure. Had good conversations throughout procedure. Very good…

Lonnie Lapacz
Lonnie Lapacz5 months ago
★★★★★

Excellent dental clinic, punctual and excellent care

Susie Piper
Susie Piper3 months ago
★★★★★

Dr V was fantastic!

Tammy Capelle
Tammy Capelle3 months ago
★★★★★

Sylvia is fantastic. I never worry about her being too rough. She’s always professional and…

Diana Schadewald
Diana Schadewald6 months ago
★★★★★

It’s a really nice clean. They have really nice people there.

Gail Buntin Blohowiak
Gail Buntin Blohowiak4 months ago
★★★★★

Great atmosphere. Lobbed my hygienist.

Sadie Salentine
Sadie Salentine3 months ago
★★★★★

Always friendly and explain what they are doing so nothing is a surprise.

Kevin Sistler
Kevin Sistler5 months ago
★★★★★

Morgan was a gem! She is really good at her job.

Judy Patz
Judy Patz4 months ago
★★★★★

I have never had a dentist/hygienist explain things to me while cleaning my teeth about…

Roger Toole
Roger Toole6 months ago
★★★★★

Everyone there is very friendly making our visit a great experience.

Robert Berndt
Robert Berndt3 months ago
★★★★★

Morgan is very professional, proficient, personable, and down to earth. Very happy with my experience!!…

Analeiyah Cruz
Analeiyah Cruz5 months ago
★★★★★

My name is amariana Cruz and I’ve never had a better experience with dental in…

Cheryl Schreiber
Cheryl Schreiber2 months ago
★★★★★

Sylvia was very respectful and treated me well.

Dannie McCoy
Dannie McCoy6 months ago
★★★★★

Great dental office. They sure know what there doing. Ver friendly.

Bill & Cathy Stone
Bill & Cathy Stone5 months ago
★★★★★

Everyone was friendly and helpful. Always a plus at a dental visit

Adam Smith
Adam Smith2 months ago
★★★★★

Great dentist, the staff are very nice

David Parsons
David Parsons3 months ago
★★★★★

Excellent service as an early walk in patient!!!

John Christiano
John Christiano5 months ago
★★★★★

I’ve been with Dr Brodhagen for about 30 years. You’ll never find a finer dentist…

B C
B C6 months ago
★★★★★

Stacy does a great job in answering all my questions and making suggestions to improve…

Jill Zelzer
Jill Zelzer5 months ago
★★★★★

Always very friendly! Enjoyed my cleaning with Morgan and was very fortunate to meet the…

Dennis Ansell
Dennis Ansell3 months ago
★★★★★

My experience was very good. The dental hygienist was very professional and precise. The dentist…

Glen Schwalbach
Glen Schwalbach4 months ago
★★★★★

Excellent focus on patient. Friendly staff. Know their stuff. Hygienist was excellent, very skilled, and…

Julie Wecker
Julie Wecker3 months ago
★★★★★

I had excellent, pain free care at Dr Brodhagen's office, trust him completely. The hygienist…

Charmaine Baranczyk
Charmaine Baranczyk3 months ago
★★★★★

Good experience Assistant very informative and pleasant. Dr. Mark always pleasant and I feel comfortable…

Suzann Parins
Suzann Parins5 months ago
★★★★★

Prepping for implant so it is always a bit unnerving but I was talked through…

Richard Giesler
Richard Giesler5 months ago
★★★★★

Best dential care a person can ever expect. They are caring, concerned and ready to…

Gloria Malcore
Gloria Malcore3 months ago
★★★★★

She is wonderful person caring about her patients. And explain everything has she goes .

Fr. Mathew Simonar
Fr. Mathew Simonar3 months ago
★★★★★

The staff is very welcoming and friendly. They also did a great job explaining every…

Debora Steffek
Debora Steffek2 months ago
★★★★★

Friendly but very professional. Excellent care by the hygienist and dentist.

Sheri Palmer
Sheri Palmer3 months ago
★★★★★

Professionals that are efficient, kind, and patient. They listen well and answer all questions. I…

Lindsey Coonen
Lindsey Coonen5 months ago
★★★★★

Dr Mark Brodhagen is the absolute best dentist ever. Excellent work, very caring and professional….

Michele Dury
Michele Dury2 months ago
★★★★★

The hygienist took her time with me. Made sure I was comfortable with everything she…

Lisa D
Lisa D4 months ago
★★★★★

I was a first time patient of Dr. Mike’s at Bay Park Smiles today. Going…

Amanda Weslow
Amanda Weslow5 months ago
★★★★★

Great place, friendly atmosphere.

Laurie Stelmach
Laurie Stelmach4 months ago
★★★★★

The staff was very friendly and helpful. Dr. explained things in an understanding manner.

Phillip Clampitt
Phillip Clampitt6 months ago
★★★★★

Great dentists and service. The best. Plus, you get good cycling stories from Mark

Derk Voskuil
Derk Voskuil4 months ago
★★★★★

Great dentist and staff! Always professional and personable.

Lisa Heaton
Lisa Heaton3 months ago
★★★★★

Nobody looks forward to seeing the dentist, but Bay Park Smiles has been wonderful and…

Alyce Kingsauer
Alyce Kingsauer3 months ago
★★★★★

Great. First appointment. They explained information well.

Thomas Van Gemert
Thomas Van Gemert5 months ago
★★★★★

Excellent care no issues. Everyone there is friendly and very competent.

Dylan Ladd
Dylan Ladd6 months ago
★★★★★

They do an amazing job at this place. I was very nervous about having surgery….

Bonnie Zak
Bonnie Zak5 months ago
★★★★★

Stacy is amazing and I love the conversations and care I received. Love all the…

Ariana Lintner
Ariana Lintner6 months ago
★★★★★

This is by far the best place to go. They are so sweet, very caring,…

Pam Lestrud
Pam Lestrud2 months ago
★★★★★

Going to the dentist was one of my fears As a child. At Bay Park…

Annie Frey
Annie Frey6 months ago
★★★★★

First time to see this dentist … entrance to reception area was very warm, welcoming…

Elizabeth Erickson
Elizabeth Erickson2 months ago
★★★★★

Always professional, friendly and they all make you feel very comfortable

Mary Jo Juley
Mary Jo Juley6 months ago
★★★★★

My hygienist Stacey is so friendly and helpful with hints and tips on maintaining good…

Us Rigging
Us Rigging5 months ago
★★★★★

Love Brodhagen Dental. They are the best. They go out of their way for you….

Mary Sell
Mary Sell3 months ago
★★★★★

Great dental facility and awesome staff they care about their patients wouldn’t go anywhere else…

Laurie Brewer
Laurie Brewer3 months ago
★★★★★

Sylvia was the best!!! Thank you!

Ramiro Rodriguez
Ramiro Rodriguez4 months ago
★★★★★

Morgan, the hygienist, was very professional snd courteous. A painless experience. Would highly recommend her.

Sandra Schulze
Sandra Schulze2 months ago
★★★★★

I have been a patient of Dr. Brodhagen for many years and have been pleased…

Megan Gunderson
Megan Gunderson5 months ago
★★★★★

Sylvia is my dental hygienist and she does a great job! She is very gentle…

dave paul
dave paul5 months ago
★★★★★

Wonderful staff, so grateful to be back!

Oliva Kilyenyi
Oliva Kilyenyi5 months ago
★★★★★

My daughter smiles 😁 is back with a confidence. She broke her front tooth while…

Janet Kersten
Janet Kersten1 month ago
★★★★★

She was excellent. Not one problem. The people up front were great and did a…

Doris Wilberg
Doris Wilberg5 months ago
★★★★★

The staff is friendly, efficient & on time.

Rose Hawker
Rose Hawker6 months ago
★★★★★

Stacey had me smiling all bright and shiny

Jakeb Thurber
Jakeb Thurber4 months ago
★★★★★

Always a great experience.

Lori Wotruba
Lori Wotruba3 months ago
★★★★★

I would recommend my family & friends to go here! Very friendly staff and they…

dan gerlikowski
dan gerlikowski3 months ago
★★★★★

Still have concerns hopefully will be fixed.

Kristen Kosman
Kristen Kosman5 months ago
★★★★★

My hygienist was amazing! She got to know me, explained to me on an easy…

Mike kramer
Mike kramer3 months ago
★★★★★

Everyone is so very friendly and helpful. The Dentist are very informational, experienced and caring.

Crystal Guevara
Crystal Guevara4 months ago
★★★★★

Nothing but great things to say. Always treated well with excellent and professional care given.

Heidi Ozminkowski
Heidi Ozminkowski5 months ago
★★★★★

Professional and caring. Morgan is kind and engaging. Billing was easy even with insurance involvement….

Mark Best
Mark Best5 months ago
★★★★★

Always have a great experience at Brodhagen/Bay Park Smiles Dental!

Joel Worman
Joel Worman2 months ago
★★★★★

Lisa, my hygienist, is the best! Professional with an amazing personality. Lisa helps so much…

Frequently Asked Filling Questions

5–10 years on average, with many lasting longer. Depends on filling size, bite forces, and oral hygiene. We check filling integrity at every recall visit.

For moderate-sized fillings, yes — modern composites are very strong. For very large restorations with high bite forces, an inlay, onlay, or crown may be more appropriate than composite.

If your amalgam fillings are intact and functioning well, there is no urgent clinical reason to replace them. If they are old, cracking, leaking, or you prefer tooth-colored restorations, replacement with composite is a reasonable choice. We evaluate each one individually.

The tooth is numbed with local anesthesia before any preparation begins — you should feel pressure but no pain. Some sensitivity for 1–3 days afterward is normal and resolves on its own.

Most plans cover composite fillings for front teeth at 100% and back teeth at the amalgam rate. Many plans now cover composite for all teeth. We verify your benefits before your appointment.

Related services

Inlays & onlays

For larger cavities where a filling is insufficient — the conservative step between a filling and a crown.

Dental crowns

When a tooth is too damaged for a filling or inlay — full coverage protection.

Teeth whitening

If you’re replacing old fillings, whitening first ensures the new composite is matched to your brightest smile.